top of page

The Modern CISO

From Security Leadership to Risk Executive

The PolarStar Way

Abstract Purple Design
Read Time
8 min
Executive Summary
The CISO role is at an inflection point. As technology becomes the business, security leadership must evolve from managing tools and tickets to managing enterprise technology risk.
 
Boards and CEOs don’t care about vulnerabilities in isolation, they care about how technology risk affects revenue, trust, and resilience. The most effective CISOs operate like Chief Risk Officers, translating security investment into clear business tradeoffs and decisions. This shift separates “ticket jockeys” from risk executives who shape strategy and enable growth.
Abstract Blue Design

Boards don't care about security. They care about risk.

According to the IANS report on the State of the CISO (2025 Summary Report), 72% of leaders holding the CISO role fall into either the functional (50%) or tactical (22%) CISO segment [1]. These leaders lack meaningful influence within their organization and typically have limited executive-level access, constraining their strategic value and professional growth.

 

Only 28% of CISO leaders fall under the Strategic segment. These leaders either report directly to the CEO or occupy a high-ranking position in the hierarchy, while maintaining regular engagement with the board, meeting at least quarterly.

If CISOs want to be more strategic, it’s more than just your reporting line and the number of board slides created. Strategy is the systematic identification, assessment and prioritization of risks aligned to business objectives. Strategy translates uncertainty into deliberate choices. 

 

To be an effective security leader, you need to understand this cold hard truth: Boards don’t care about security. They care about risk. 

 

Leaders at the highest level of an organization are in the Risk Management business. 

 

What has traditionally been a deeply technical function focused on perimeter defense, incident response, and vulnerability remediation is evolving into something far more consequential: an executive mandate to manage and communicate both technology and engineering risk at the enterprise level. 

 

Similar to how the introduction of the Chief Risk Officer (CRO) transformed how financial institutions understood and governed risk, the next generation of trusted and durable SaaS companies will elevate CISOs who operate as risk executives, not security ticket managers. 

 

These CISOs will oversee risk associated with technology and engineering decisions across people, processes, systems, and 3rd party dependencies, and have the fortitude to translate security investments into business outcomes that boards and CEOs understand.

​

A Brief History of the CISO Role

Early Days: Technical Custodian

​

The CISO role emerged in 1996, largely in response to growing connectivity, early cybercrime and high-profile breaches. It was Citigroup that appointed the world’s first CISO in 1995 in response to being hacked out of $10M by a nation state group [2],[3]. Steve Katz was selected due to his deep technical background in early computing and experience working on product lifecycle and quality assurance. 

 

Early CISOs were often senior technologists tasked with protecting infrastructure and data from external threats. 

 

The Compliance Era: Control & Audit Focus

 

As regulations like SOX, PCI-DSS, HIPAA and eventually GDPR emerged, the CISO role expanded to include compliance and audit readiness. Security programs became more formalized, revolving specifically around incident response, but were (and are) still largely reactive. 

 

As the CISO role evolved here, CISOs became control operators with a narrower focus on enterprise security. While policies, tools and attestations were being put in place, the CISO function remained centered on activities rather than outcomes. Risk was implied and assumed, but rarely articulated in business terms. Executive leadership viewed the security role more as insurance, than a business enabler. 

 

The Modern Reality: Technology is the Business

​​

These days, nearly every organization has now become a “technology company”, building products for either in-house or user-facing consumption. In SaaS and cloud-native companies today, technology is no longer a support function. 

 

It is the business. 

 

Engineering velocity, platform reliability, data handling, and third-party integrations directly determine revenue, customer trust, and enterprise value. Despite this shift, many organizations are still stuck in the Compliance Era.

 

CISOs are raring to break out, but are battling against the executive team perspective that security is not a business enabler. These leaders are not helping their cause when they are reporting on and evaluating their business on operational artifacts: vulnerability counts, mean-time-to-remediate, tool coverage, and audit results. 

 

The Chief Risk Officer Parallel: A Useful Blueprint

 

The financial industry faced a similar moment in the mid- to late-1990s. Deregulation, consolidation, the development of new financial instruments and the growth and integration of capital markets were all pulling financial institutions into a broader, ever more complex operating environment [4]. The Basel Accords accelerated the number of individuals assigned to the CRO post. 

 

CROs were not responsible for executing every control or transaction. Their mandate was to:

  • Identify and categorize risk

  • Quantify exposure

  • Align risk appetite with business strategy

  • Communicate risk clearly to executives and boards

 

CROs don’t necessarily own the risk inherent in the business, rather they provide the visibility, analysis, and recommendations regarding risk to their operating peers: CEO, CFO, COO. 

 

Businesses made better investment decisions by having a CRO. By centralizing risk management in this way, it enabled financial firms to make decisions based on a better appreciation of the relationship between risk and reward.

 

SaaS companies are now facing an analogous challenge with technology and engineering risk. 

 

Why the CISO Must Become a Technology Risk Executive

 

For the modern CISO, closing vulnerability tickets isn’t the goal of your department. Reducing material risk to the business is. The vulnerability tickets that have become so prolific in our day-to-day operations is simply a means to manage risk.  

 

A backlog of vulnerabilities tells you very little without the context:

 

  • Which asset generates revenue?

  • Which systems handle regulated or sensitive data?

  • Which vulnerabilities meaningfully increase the likelihood or impact of business description?

 

CISOs who operate as risk leaders reframe the conversation from “How many issues do we have” to “Which risks matter most, and why?”

​

​

Shifting From Tools & Tasks to Decisions & Tradeoffs

 

Every security investment is a tradeoff - capital, engineering time, opportunity cost. Boards and CEOs don’t need a dashboard of CVEs, they need clarity on decisions.

 

  • What risks are we accepting?

  • What risks are we mitigating?

  • What risks are we avoiding?

 

The CISO is uniquely positioned to answer these questions if they adopt a risk lens. 

 

A Structural Shift: CTOs and CIOs in the CISO Office

 

As CISOs evolve into risk executives, an important organizational shift follows: technology leaders increasingly become stakeholders within the CISO office. 

 

This doesn't mean the CISO owns engineering or IT. Rather, the CISO provides the risk framework in which CTOs and CIOs remain accountable for execution. As a result, risk tradeoffs are made explicitly, not implicitly. 

 

In this model:

  • Engineering decisions are evaluated based on risk impact

  • Architecture choices are assessed through resilience and exposure

  • Delivery speed is balanced against acceptable risk (defined by executive leadership) 

 

The CISO becomes the connective tissue between technology execution and business risk tolerance. 


 

The End of the “Ticket Jockey” CISO

 

The market is increasingly crowded with security leaders who equate effectiveness with activity. 

 

“Ticket Jockey” CISOs:

  • Optimize for volume of issues closed

  • Lead with tool-centric narratives

  • Struggle to articulate impact beyond vulnerability metrics

 

Risk Management CISOs:

  • Speak the language of finance, operations and growth

  • Communicate risk in relative and decision-oriented terms

  • Align security strategy directly to business objectives

 

These are the leaders boards trust and companies retain. 

 

What the Future CISO Looks Like

 

The most impactful CISOs of the next decade will:

 

  • Operate as enterprise risk executives

  • Own technology risk taxonomy and prioritization

  • Translate security investment into business outcomes

  • Enable, not block, product and engineering velocity

 

These CISOs will still care deeply about vulnerabilities, incidents, and controls, but primarily for how they affect the organization’s risk posture. It becomes less about counting issues and more about understanding what those issues mean for the business, so that decisions can be made on how to operate safely knowing they are unavoidable. 

Risk is the Differentiator

 

CISOs who can clearly identify, manage, and communicate risk will not only be more effective, they will fundamentally change the trajectory of their organizations. 

 

Just how CROs have become indispensable to financial institutions, risk-centric CISOs will become central to the most trusted and resilient SaaS companies. 

 

For SaaS companies, the product is the business. And it’s for that reason that this evolution of CISOs is inevitable. 

 

The future belongs to CISOs who recognize that security is a lever, not a destination, and that risk is the language of leadership. 

References

[1] Institute for Applied Network Security Research (IANS), State of the CISO 2025, Jan.14, 2025. Available: https://www.iansresearch.com/resources/all-blogs/post/security-blog/2025/01/14/build-ciso-strategic-impact-and-visibility--state-of-the-ciso--2025-is-live!
 

[2] S. Morgan, Backstory Of The World’s First Chief Information Security Officer, Cybercrime Magazine, Oct. 13, 2020. Available: https://cybersecurityventures.com/backstory-of-the-worlds-first-chief-information-security-officer/
 

[3] International Information System Security Certification Consortium (ISC2), First CISO Steve Katz Passes Away, Dec. 19, 2023. Available: https://www.isc2.org/Insights/2023/12/First-CISO-Steve-Katz-Passes-Away
 

[4] Economist Intelligence Unit, The evolving role of the CRO, The Economist, 2005. Available: https://graphics.eiu.com/files/ad_pdfs/EIU_CRO_WP2.pdf

bottom of page